Bloody Sunday
OK, the title is a bit dramatic. One thing I’ve done very little of on this blog is provide commentary on abortion. So often, gay rights and abortion rights end up in the same camp. From the right, both are what makes the left evil and a disgrace to human kind. Often, court rulings for both issues hinge on a “right to privacy” enumerated by the Supreme Court in Roe V. Wade, the federal court case just filed against Prop 8 in California hinges on that very right. The most obvious similarity is that they are both social issues that are at the top of the agenda for both sides of the aisle.
Dr. George Tiller, who remained one of the nation’s few providers of late-term abortions through decades of protests and attacks, was shot and killed Sunday in a church where he was serving as an usher and his wife was in the choir.
…Long a focus of national anti-abortion groups, including a summer-long protest in 1991, Tiller was serving as an usher during Sunday morning services when he was shot in the foyer of Reformation Lutheran Church, Stolz said.
…”We just thought a child had come in with a balloon and it had popped, had gone up and hit the ceiling and popped,” [congregation member Adam] Watkins said.
Another usher came in and told the congregation to remain seated, then escorted Tiller’s wife out. “When she got to the back doors, we heard her scream, and so we knew something bad had happened,” Watkins said.
I’ll have to admit that the name George Tiller was not a name I knew anything about. You see, being a male, and being gay has put me in a class of people who have very little use for any sort of abortion rights and I’ve never really felt that it was my place to express an opinion about this issue when it is extremely unlikely to ever come into play in my personal life. As it goes however, I can have an opinion and in the words of others, I believe it should be legal and extremely rare.
Having said that I want to focus more here on the social commentary involved in this incident. Today a man was assassinated because he was providing a legal service to women who were seeking to terminate their pregnancy. This practice is not illegal, he was breaking no laws (no matter how controversial it is). It is the zeal of the assassin that worries me. It’s been a LONG time since we’ve heard reports of abortion clinic bombings and shootings that were quite common 10 years ago. There are always protests when Congress is forced to uphold what at this point is considered ’settled law”, especially when new SCOUTS judges are being considered. In the blogosphere, pundants are wondering if the political atmosphere is so explosive right now that the fringe groups (who are applauding this shooting) are making themselves known again. Are the fundamentalists so marginalized now that they do not have the political power which had 10 years ago starting to break into sect like groups who are plotting domestic terrorism? I don’t know the answer to that but with this issue and of course with the gay marriage debate, it is very clear that there is a small but vocal minority of people in this country who, because they are not getting what they want, have begun to turn towards violence to accomplish their goals and this is where my problem is. Take just a minute and parallel an abortion provider who provides a legal abortion to a woman with a justice of the peace who provides a legal marriage to a gay couple. Both are (or may soon be) completely acceptable in terms of the written law, but the services being provided remain deeply divisive in practice and put people at risk.
I have a hard time with violence. I agree that abortion might be considered murder but I disagree that we should be playing a tit for tat game here. My blood is deeply anti-violence. I have a hard time with action movies, because, even while I know they are fiction, there is something unsettling about seeing someone get shot in the face, even if it is Batman. I read every day in the gay media about gay people who are beaten up, some who are killed, some who, through no fault of their own are victimized over and over again at the hands of people so convinced that their view is the only correct way to solve a problem. I have a very difficult time understanding why we, as a human species, have yet to learn how to live with the differences among us. Why must I, as a gay man, be concerned for my own safety because I am part of a target class? Why must an abortion provider, who is licensed by the state they are practicing in and providing a legal service, have to wear a bullet proof vest just to go to work?
Clearly I don’t have answers to those questions but I thought it was time that I weigh in on the issue. I know I can be overly dramatic and highly verbally critical of groups of people who disagree with my position on gay rights. A blog like this allows me to be one sided, to share it with the world and pretty much say that if you don’t like it, than fuck you. My words and my feelings however can never translate into violent acts against other people. I know I must protect myself from people who might do me harm but why? Should I just accept that I have to live like that? I know full well that if hit, I’d never hit back. I just don’t do that sort of thing even when faced with serious injury I would rather stand and take it knowing that reciprocation of violence perpetuates and increases the problem. I’d much prefer to have a discussion with you and agree to disagree or work with you to find a compromise or a solution to our problem. I had this anti-violence condition even as a kid. Schoolyard scuffles with me were always one sided because I didn’t fight back. I simply had no use for it. Thus, I never got into many scuffles because it just was not very rewarding for the other side! I do fear that when people are marginalized they can become violent. I do fear that the more gay rights are gained, the more it pisses off those who are against us which may lead to violence. I do feel that this abortion provider was killed because abortion is considered a non-starter in today’s liberal climate, it’s legal and it’s not likely to change and that pisses some people off. I fear that gay marriage may soon land in the same camp as abortion rights and that married gay couples (or people who provide marriage licenses to gay couples) will become targets.
This is rhetorical and I’m not looking for your answers personally but what are your feeling on hot button social issues? Are you a person who solves problems using violence or are you a person who solves problems with communication knowing that the big picture and the fact that regardless of what we each think about an issue we all must continue to live side by side on this planet? I should have been a Quaker.












